Windermere Club & Butler Bay, Orlando, Florida  ·  A Local History

The 155 Acres Nobody Was Allowed to Build On


A gated neighborhood west of Orlando was built wrapped around a golf course, and the whole point of the place was the open ground in the middle. Then the course closed, somebody did the math on 95 new houses, and the county had to decide out loud what all that empty room was actually for.

A 1936 aerial photograph of orange groves laid out in long patterned rows among a chain of lakes near Windermere, with the words Isleworth Grove lettered across the bottom.
Open ground from the air, the Butler Chain, 1936
This is what room looked like. The Isleworth grove on the Butler Chain near Windermere, photographed from the air in 1936, thousands of acres of patterned ground running down to the lakes. Chase & Co., Chase Collection, University of Florida; via UCF RICHES. Flip the trees for fairways and you have the shape of the modern story.

There’s a neighborhood west of Orlando, out past the town of Windermere, where the houses were built facing a golf course the way other houses face the street. For thirty years that was the deal out there: a gate at the road, big lots, and a long green nobody could ever build on running right through the middle of everything. Then one spring the course just… stopped. Mowers quiet, flags down, the grass going shaggy on 155 acres that every back porch looked out on.

And the question that came next is a strange one for Central Florida, a place that fills an empty acre faster than almost anywhere in the country. Who owns a golf course after the golf is gone, and is anybody allowed to put houses on it?

A neighborhood built around a hole in its own middle

The place is Butler Bay, and the lakeside stretch of it that people call the Windermere Club. It went in during the 1980s on old grove-and-pasture land west of the historic town, and it was laid out the way a lot of Florida was laid out in those years: a developer takes a big piece of ground, draws a golf course down the center, and sells the lots around the edges for the view. The course here ran to about 155 acres. And here’s the part that matters later, when the plat was recorded, the development rights to that course land were dedicated to Orange County. On paper, the open ground was supposed to stay open ground.

So the room wasn’t an accident or a leftover. It was the product. Nobody pays a premium for a half-acre lot behind a gate because of the half acre. They pay for everything they can see past it and never have to mow.

The town that was always about room

None of this was a new idea out here. It’s the whole reason Windermere exists in the first place. In 1887 an Englishman named John Dawe platted a little village on the narrow neck of land between two lakes and named it after Windermere, in the English Lake District, because the water reminded him of home. What he was really selling was space, lots on high ground between the lakes, in a part of Florida that was mostly pine, palmetto, and open range.

A small white board-and-batten building with a metal gable roof standing among trees and shrubs, a historical plaque beside its door.
One of the first things they built
Start small, add on later. Windermere’s 1890 schoolhouse, later the Parramore house, still standing in the trees, photographed in recent years. Via Wikimedia Commons (Ebyabe, CC BY 2.5). A small board-and-batten building was how a Florida place like this got started: put up one thing you need, then add the next when there’s money for it.

The people who came did what people did all over frontier Florida. They claimed their acres and built up a piece at a time, a house first, then a kitchen out back away from the heat, then a barn, then a grove once the land was clear. Nobody finished a Florida homestead in a season. You got your room and you added onto it as life asked you to, because the ground was sitting right there to add onto.

And for a long while the thing they added was oranges. By the 1920s the land around Windermere was groves, worked by crews who came through the rows on ladders, and the town had houses and stores and a rail platform to ship the fruit north.

A posed 1904 photograph of three grove workers standing with picking pails in a Windermere citrus grove.
Grove hands, the Windermere lakes, 1904
Somebody worked every acre. Three hands posed with their pails, from the Isleworth grove operation on the Windermere lakes, 1904. Chase & Co., Chase Collection, University of Florida; via UCF RICHES. The groves were the first thing that filled all this room.

A grove is a slow, patient use of land, you plant trees and wait most of a decade before they really pay. It only makes sense if you’ve got room to spare and time to let it work. That’s the bargain this whole corner of the county was built on: get more ground than you need right now, and let it earn its keep later.

An elevated view across rows of orange trees running down to a lake near Orlando around 1900, a tall packing shed standing among the trees.
Groves down to the water, near Orlando, about 1900
Room with water on one side. Orange groves running down to a lake near Orlando, around 1900, a packing shed in the trees, grove to the tree line. Detroit Publishing Co., Library of Congress. A representative Central Florida grove-on-the-water of the era, the kind that covered the Windermere lakes.
The gate and the golf were new. The thing underneath them, get room, keep room, build what you want on it, was the oldest habit in Windermere.What the story is really about

You can see the habit written down. The old county maps don’t just show the lakes; they show the land cut into squares with the owners’ names printed right on their parcels, a whole county drawn as a record of people getting their piece and holding it.

An 1890 map of Orange County, Florida, a grid of townships and sections with lakes across the western half and the surnames of landowners printed on their parcels.
Orange County, 1890, the room, carved into names
Room, on paper. A map of Orange County from 1890, townships and sections, the chain of lakes down the west side, and the names of whoever had claimed their ground printed on their parcels. J. O. Fries and E. W. Smith & Co., Library of Congress.

When the freezes won, the room stayed

The groves didn’t last. Hard freezes came through Central Florida, one bad winter after another over the decades, and each one chipped at the trees. And once Orlando started growing west toward the lakes, grove land this close to a city was worth far more with houses on it than with oranges, lakefront grove land most of all. The fruit went. The thing that had made the fruit possible did not. The room stayed, and the clear water stayed, and that turned out to be the whole inheritance.

Which is where the golf course comes back in. By the 1980s the way you cashed in the room wasn’t a grove, it was a subdivision wrapped around an amenity. Butler Bay’s course opened in that decade, and for a generation it did exactly what a grove once did, it was the reason the land around it was worth something. Every lot borrowed its value from all that open green nobody could build on.

The day they had to vote on empty space

Then the course closed, in the spring of 2016. The owner pointed to falling membership and the cost of keeping the thing watered and mowed, which is a real problem all over golf-course Florida. And a closed course is a strange kind of asset: 155 acres of prime, gated, lakefront-adjacent ground sitting there growing weeds. Anybody looking at it with a developer’s eye sees the obvious move. Put houses on it.

That’s exactly what got proposed, a plan to carve roughly 95 new home lots out of part of the old course and leave the rest as ponds and green space. On its face it’s reasonable. The golf is gone; the land is valuable; fill some of it in.

But remember the fine print from the 1980s. Those development rights had been dedicated to the county. So it wasn’t the owner’s call alone, and it wasn’t the neighbors’ either. In the fall of 2016 the Orange County Commission took it up, and they voted, unanimously, not to hand those rights back. No 95 houses. The 155 acres would stay the 155 acres.

A neighborhood that had quietly understood, for thirty years, that the empty ground was the real asset, and when somebody finally tried to fill it, the county agreed.The turn

Sit with how odd that is. In a metro that paves whatever it can, a government looked at 155 buildable acres inside a gate and decided the best use of it was to stay open. The room won the vote. The thing Windermere had been protecting since 1887, mostly out of habit and taste, got protected one more time, this time on the record, by a show of hands.

What’s out there now

The lakes are still the reason, the way they always were. The Butler Chain, the string of connected lakes Windermere sits among, is still clear, still the thing people are really buying when they buy out here.

A present-day aerial photograph of a broad Butler Chain lake at Windermere, large waterfront homes and a smaller lily pond along the tree-lined shore.
The Butler Chain from the air, today
The same room, a century on. A Butler Chain lake at Windermere from the air today, big waterfront lots backing onto open water. A present-day aerial. The open ground and clear water that once held groves now hold the view.

And the town itself still guards its room the plain old-fashioned way. Windermere famously keeps many of its streets unpaved, sand roads it spends real money not to pave, because the dust and the slowness are part of staying spread out and quiet instead of turning into every other Orlando suburb.

A present-day Windermere intersection where a wide unpaved sand road meets a paved street, old oaks and a pink house in the background.
Still unpaved, on purpose
Room you can feel under the tires. A sand street in Windermere, 2005, the town keeps many of its roads deliberately unpaved. Via Wikimedia Commons. A present-day photograph.

Down by the water there’s a town park on Lake Down where anybody can put a boat on the chain, and out past the gates the Tibet-Butler preserve keeps a stretch of the old wild hammock exactly as it was, ground that was never going to be a grove or a fairway or a lot, left as room for its own sake.

A present-day wooden boardwalk curving through a shaded Florida hammock of oaks and ferns at Tibet-Butler Preserve near Windermere.
The wild edge, Tibet-Butler Preserve, today
Ground left as ground. The boardwalk through the hammock at Tibet-Butler Preserve, beside the Butler Chain near Windermere. Via Wikimedia Commons. A modern photograph.
A present-day view of the open, mowed Lake Down town park at Windermere, shade trees along a grassy shoreline on the Butler Chain.
Lake Down town park, today
Public room on the chain. The town park on Lake Down at Windermere, present day, open ground and a way onto the Butler Chain for anyone. Town of Windermere; via Wikimedia Commons. A modern photograph.

So the golf course sits quiet, and the fairways nobody plays on are still off-limits to the bulldozers, a 155-acre green that outlived the game it was built for, kept empty by a county that decided, for once, that empty was the point. A grove became a golf course became a protected open field, and under all three it was the same stubborn Windermere idea the whole time: the room is worth more than whatever you’d put on it.

A present-day note · Orange Tiny Homes

The room was always the point.

Strip the gate and the golf off of Butler Bay and what’s left is the oldest Central-Florida instinct there is: get a piece of ground with room on it, and the room is the valuable part. A county commission voted to protect 155 acres of it. The homesteaders on that 1890 map protected theirs a barn and a back cottage at a time. Nobody out here ever finished their place in one go, they added on as life asked them to, because the room was sitting right there to add onto.

That instinct still pays, and the thing people build on their room now has a name, an ADU, an accessory dwelling unit. That’s what we do. A granny flat so a parent can live close with their own front door. A guest house. A rental out back that helps carry the mortgage. A tiny home in the far corner of the lot. Same move the whole town was built on, put what you need on the room you’ve got, just with a kitchen, a bathroom, and a permit.

And you don’t need a vote of the county commission, or a point on the Butler Chain, to do it. All across the greater Orlando area, the roomier lots out toward Windermere and Gotha, sure, but plenty of ordinary yards in Conway, Pine Hills, Azalea Park and unincorporated Orange County too, the space is already there. What actually decides it comes down to your own address:

The real answer to “is there room out back for this?” isn’t a guess, it’s a handful of facts about your lot. That part we can check for you.

Put in your address and we’ll pull what your parcel allows and tell you whether a granny flat, guest house, rental, or tiny home actually fits, before you spend a dollar on drawings.

Start the ADU Fit Check→
Sources & Photo Credits

On the history

Where sources differ or detail is thin: the exact opening year, membership history, and course architect of the Butler Bay / Windermere Country Club course are reported variously in secondary (real-estate and local) sources and are given here only in general terms; the load-bearing facts used on this page, the roughly 155-acre size, the 1985–1986 zoning and plat with development rights dedicated to Orange County, the April 2016 closure, the roughly 95-lot redevelopment proposal, and the unanimous October 18, 2016 county vote to keep those rights, are drawn from the county-records summary cited above. The deeper founding details (the 1885 Scott purchase and naming) come to us through long-repeated local tradition rather than a single primary document and are presented as such. Full notes are in source-record.md beside this page.

Photographs & documents

  1. Isleworth grove aerial, 1936 (hero), an aerial photograph of the Isleworth grove on the Butler Chain of Lakes near Windermere, thousands of acres of patterned grove among the lakes, March 1936. Chase & Co.; Chase Collection, University of Florida; via RICHES of Central Florida, University of Central Florida. A photograph of the Windermere lakes themselves, not a stand-in. File: windermere-grove-from-the-air-1936. richesmi.cah.ucf.edu/omeka/items/show/592
  2. Windermere’s 1890 schoolhouse, present day, the small board-and-batten building put up as Windermere’s schoolhouse in 1890, later the Parramore house, still standing; photographed in recent years. Wikimedia Commons (user Ebyabe, CC BY 2.5). A modern photograph of the real building. File: windermere-1890-schoolhouse-today. commons.wikimedia.org
  3. Grove workers, Windermere, 1904, three workers with picking pails in the Isleworth grove on the Windermere lakes, 1904. Chase & Co.; Chase Collection, University of Florida; via UCF RICHES. A photograph of the Windermere groves themselves, not a stand-in. File: isleworth-grove-workers-windermere-1904. richesmi.cah.ucf.edu/omeka/items/show/599
  4. Orange groves down to a lake near Orlando, c.1900, an elevated view of orange groves running to a lake, a packing shed in the trees. Detroit Publishing Co., Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Division. A representative Central Florida grove-on-the-water of the era. File: orange-grove-down-to-a-lake-c1900. loc.gov/item/2016809289
  5. Map of Orange County, Florida, 1890, townships, sections, lakes, and landowners’ names, drawn by J. O. Fries and published by E. W. Smith & Co., Philadelphia, 1890. Library of Congress Geography & Map Division. File: orange-county-1890-map. loc.gov/item/2012592407
  6. The Butler Chain from the air, present day, a present-day aerial of a Butler Chain lake at Windermere, large waterfront lots along the shore. Via the locked-in image-sourcing method; clearly a modern image. File: butler-chain-from-the-air-today. windermerefl.com
  7. A Windermere sand road, 2005, a present-day photograph of one of Windermere’s deliberately unpaved sand streets. Wikimedia Commons (user NE2, CC0). A modern photograph. File: windermere-sand-road-today. commons.wikimedia.org
  8. Lake Down town park, present day, a present-day photograph of the Town of Windermere’s park on Lake Down, on the Butler Chain. Town of Windermere, FL; via Wikimedia Commons (public domain). A modern photograph. File: lake-down-town-park-today. commons.wikimedia.org
  9. Tibet-Butler Preserve, present day, a present-day photograph of the boardwalk through the wild hammock at Tibet-Butler Preserve, beside the Butler Chain near Windermere. Via Wikimedia Commons. A modern photograph. File: tibet-butler-preserve-today. commons.wikimedia.org

Original downloads and the full research record are kept alongside this page in assets/images/originals/ and source-record.md. Several images are photographs of the right era and region, used to show what the Windermere groves, the lakes, and the town looked like; each is labeled above as specific to its subject or as representative. No historical image was altered in a way that changes its content, the aerial and the county map were cropped at the edges and downscaled, and the Polaroid frames and handwritten notes are CSS added around the images, never onto them.