Drive out the west side of Orlando, past the sand roads and the chain of lakes around Windermere, and you’ll pass a gated neighborhood with a grove right there in its name: Tilden’s Grove. There is not an orange tree in it. A few minutes on, where the golf mansions start, you’re standing on what a citrus family out of Philadelphia once called the Isle of Worth, thirteen hundred acres of oranges they were so certain the cold could never reach that they named the whole place after the bet.
Both names are headstones. And the odd thing about this corner of Orange County is how many of its priciest addresses are quietly named for the thing that used to grow where the houses are now.
So here’s the question worth asking, standing on a lawn in a place called a grove with no grove in sight: what were they so sure about, and what happened to it?
The bet on the lakes
Start with why anyone planted oranges here in the first place. An orange tree is a tropical thing living somewhere that gets the occasional killing cold snap, and a grower’s whole life rides on guessing where the cold won’t settle. Water is the trick. A big lake holds the day’s heat and stays warmer than the land around it on a freezing night, and it breathes that warmth back onto the shore. So the ground around a deep chain of lakes was, in theory, the safest citrus ground in the state.
Two brothers from Philadelphia, Joshua and Sydney Chase, believed that theory enough to buy into it. Their company dated to 1884; by 1886 they had put together a grove on the Butler Chain near Windermere that ran to thirteen hundred acres. They called it the Isle of Worth, because the trees out there seemed to shrug off the cold snaps that burned other groves. The name was a brag with a reason behind it.
And they weren’t the only ones. Windermere itself got its start in 1887, when an Englishman named John Dawe laid out a town between the lakes and named it after a lake back home in England. By 1910 a local improvement company was selling the place as a citrus paradise, and thousands of acres of orange trees went in around the water. For a stretch there, this was one of the largest citrus regions on earth. The lakes were the whole argument.
What a grove that size really is
A grove of thirteen hundred acres isn’t a quiet orchard. It’s a small industry with a town attached. Somebody has to bud the trees, nurse them through the bugs, pick the fruit by hand, grade it, pack it, and move it north before it spoils. The people who did all that lived right out on the grove, in houses among the trees.
They draped whole trees and smoked them to kill the scale. Ledgers from the Isleworth grove in the 1930s list dozens of families, Black and white, living and working on the place, their wages logged season by season. The grove was their town the way a mill or a mine was somebody else’s.
And the fruit went a long way. Isleworth oranges were good enough that the company carried a display of them all the way to the New York World’s Fair, stacked in crates under a painted Florida sky for the crowds out in Queens. About as far from a sand road in Orange County as an orange could get.
The two cold nights
The trouble with betting your fortune on a warm lake is that it only has to be wrong once.
In the winter of 1894 and 1895 the cold came down the peninsula in two blows. The first, in December, froze the fruit on the trees, and people told themselves the trees would pull through. Then in February a second freeze came through and split the trunks open to the root, and groves that had been somebody’s whole life were standing deadwood by spring.
What that winter did to the money still reads like a crash. Grove land that had been selling for a thousand dollars an acre went begging at ten. Men who’d been rich on paper packed up and left the state. The Isle of Worth, the grove too charmed to freeze, froze right along with everybody else.
But they came back. One of the Chase brothers had gone out to California after the freeze; in 1904 he came home, and they replanted, one young budded tree at a time, and the grove grew up a second time. For most of a century after that, the oranges held. The lakes did their job most winters. The bet, mostly, paid.
And then it happened again
The second ending came slower and stuck. Through the 1980s a run of hard freezes hit Central Florida almost back to back, the worst of them around Christmas of 1989, and this time the groves north of Orlando didn’t come back. The growers who could afford to start over did it a hundred miles south, down toward Lake Okeechobee where the cold rarely reaches. Up here, nobody replanted.
What a frozen grove is worth, it turns out, depends on what else you can do with the land, and by the 1980s the answer around Windermere was: quite a lot. The Chase family sold the Isle of Worth in 1984. The trees came down, and the chain of lakes that had been the citrus argument became a different kind of argument, for waterfront lots. One by one the old grove tracts turned into gated neighborhoods.
The land out here was never really about oranges. The oranges were just the first thing worth putting on all that room.
What the freeze couldn’t take
So go looking for the groves today and you won’t find them. You’ll find golf courses and guard gates and street signs doing the remembering. Keene’s Pointe. Isleworth, on the grove that kept its old name. And Tilden’s Grove, which borrowed a pioneer citrus family’s name and the plain old word for what used to be here, and set both on a sign at the entrance.
But the thing those groves were actually built on is still sitting right there, because you can’t freeze room. The lots out here run big. The Butler Chain is still the center of everything. And Windermere, stubbornly, still won’t pave most of its streets: miles of them are packed sand under the oaks, posted local traffic only, because the people who live on them keep voting the asphalt down.
Drive one of those sand lanes at dusk and the place tells on itself. The ground is the same ground. The lakes are the same lakes the Chases bet on. The only thing that changed is what people decided was worth planting on all that space.
Tilden’s Grove has no grove. The Isle of Worth has no oranges. Two cold nights in 1895 and a run of them in the 1980s saw to that. But the room those groves were planted on, the wide lots and the quiet water and the sand roads nobody will pave, outlasted the fruit and the freezes both. Out here the land was always the asset. The oranges were just the first crop it grew.